300's Inaccuracies
The movie 300 was a great movie about the battle of Thermopylae. The battle of Thermopylae was a battle between the Persians, Spartans, and their allies that took place at the Pass of Thermopylae or Hot Gates. The movie had some historical inaccuracies. Some of them were necessary, but some were really disappointing.
In the movie, King Leonidas was portrayed as being in his mid thirties to his early forties. According to Professor Paul Cartledge, a world expert on Athens and Sparta in the Classical Age, King Leonidas was in his fifties or maybe even sixties when he died at the battle. However, I agree with Frank Millers (writer and illustrator of the comic 300) and Hollywoods depiction of King Leonidas. Who would want to watch an old guy fight? I think it was necessary to portray him as a warrior in his thirties.
The Frank Millers Immortals of Persia looked like phantoms of the night. They were clad in black, masked, and armed with two swords. The real Immortals were heavily armed infantry with decorated clothing. I prefer Frank Millers depiction because it gave them a scarier look. Frank Miller turned them into something to fear.
The Spartans shields in 300 each had a lambda, an inverted V, adorned onto it even though, each Spartan was supposed to have his own emblem adorned on his own shield. I think Zack Snyder, the director of the movie, was being lazy, but the shields showed how Spartas army is a team and that every soldier in their army worked as one big unit especially in the phalanx formation.
The portrayal of Xerxes was very false. In the movie he had nothing on but underwear, was bald, and had many piercings of gold rings on his body. He really wore a white...
Reviews of: "300's Inaccuracies"
:
This analysis is interesting in a way that such a young student (year 9) could be able to pick up these details in the movie! Good criticism..I think!
The critique of the movie and show of inaccuracies was well detailed
Was Leonidas' visit to the Oracles actually relevant or somewhat similar to an event that took place before the battle?
More Middle Eastern History
essays:
Crucial Battles of the Persian Wars
... the Persians chances of victory. The Greeks decided send troops to guard the pass of Thermopylae, and ... the two battles were of equal importance. This can be seen when Bury says, "The battle of Plataea shares with Salamis the dignity of being decisive battles in the worlds history ...
Contributions of ancient egypt
... that of today's modern dentistry. Since the average life span of an Egyptian was thirty years, funeral arrangements had to be made early and ...
Significance of The Battle of Taurs
... won by the "invincible" Arabs, that a more dominant population of people in the U.S. and in the world would be Muslim. This battle was so significant to us ... bulwark of ice; and with great blows of their swords they ...
What and where is the Ark of the Covenant?
... out of a form of wood that is interminable and covered with gold. Four gold rings were placed on the Ark, in which two rods of wood covered in gold were ... be appointed, as has been done for centuries. The community says they received the Ark from King Solomon's son, Menelik, who brought it to them for ...
Ancient Egypt - Spartan religion speech (refered to sources)
... day of the months and they said they could not take the field until the moon was full." Frank J. Frost also tells us that "The Spartans has obviously committed themselves to assisting the Athenians an any clash with the Persians ...
The Battle of Salamis
... Battle of Artemisium. Besides, The Spartans wanted to return Peloponnese and prevent the Persians from ... series of conflicts between the Greek world and the Persian Empire that started about 500 BC and continued until 448 BC. The Battle of Salamis was one of the ...
Importance of army, diplomacy, gender roles and social structure of ramesside period
... importance of army (Hornung) Continued traditional that king's individuality receded completely into background behind his role. -Ramses II, reigned 66yrs have no depictions as ...
Ornament of the World Book Report
... , in the mid-tenth century, declared itself the center of the Islamic world. 4 ... elegance.--Unknown2.Of Pedro, King of SpainNoble and honoured Pedro, glory of Spain ... theme of Tolerance. 6.By reading this book, were your views on the middle ages changed?Personally, my beliefs in the Middle ages were ...
Love the movie...but damn it, you're right
...ya... turns out it WASN'T completely accurate...nice critique... put 'and' instead of 'an' "...could fight against and army..."
nice job
2 out of 2 people found this comment useful.