Comparison on immigrant mothers experience in the short stories Rules of the Game" by Amy Tan, and "Who's Irish" by Gish Jen
The short stories" Rules of the Game" by Amy Tan, and "Who's Irish" by Gish Jen deal with immigrant mothers and their experiences with their daughters. Each story tells how their is a strain on the mother-daughter relationship and a gap with culture.
In "Rules of the Game", Amy Tan's narrator is Waverly Jong. Waverly is forced throughout the story to discover what game she is playing, and what rules she must follow in order to succeed in life. Waverly's chess playing becomes a metaphor for her struggle with her greatest opponent, her mother. At first Waverly's mother supported her but the mother-daughter relationship is strained by the end of the story. Waverly's mother gave her chang, (a small piece of red jade) (pg. 472), when she had her first tournament and told her this is for luck (pg. 472). This showed support for Waverly but after the tournament, Wavelry's mother told her "Next time win more, lose less" (pg. 472). This showed that no matter what Waverly did to succeed, her mother would always have something negative to say. Toward the end of the story, Waverly ran away. After she came back home, her mother said " We not concerning for this girl. This girl not have concern for us" (pg. 474) while Waverly stood their for her punishment. Waverlys' mother was disappointed in her and was upset that she only thought of herself.
In " Who's Irish" the narrator was a immigrant Chinese grandmother. This story is based on her thoughts and feelings about being a grandmother. The point of view focuses on the grandmother and begins the story talking about her background. The story is arranged in chronological order. First, Sophie Shea, the granddaughter is introduced. Then Sophie's families background. The narrator describes herself as fierce (pg.
More Comparative Essays
essays:
Compare the Similarities of short stories, poetry and drama
... a feeling, for an example the mood can be eerie or sad. Figures of speech are another element that is shared by drama, short stories, and poems. Figures of speech are expressions such as a hyperbole or metaphor that ...
Comparative Essay on the Beginnings of The Picture of Dorian Gray and Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.
... some of the messages and ideas of the novel. This is why I thought that ... a feeling that the day is endless and that it is dragging itself on, making Wotton long for something to happen. Moreover, it is as if the delineation of the noises, is getting always further away from the character listening, by ...
Very Short Stories by Jack Spearing
... falling, and there was nothing she could do. Not now. Knafe "Knafe" "There's no need to taunt me" was his reply. But they didn't know who he was. That name had been born out of the game he ...
Comparison of Martha and Susan (Comparison of main characters from Fay Weldon's short story The Weekend and Doris Lessing's short story To Room 19)
... s short story The Weekend and Susan is a main character from Doris Lessings short story To Room 19. These two key female characters try to cope with roles of wife, and mother ...
How does Dickens make the reader feel sympathy for Pip in extracts from 'Great Expectations'?
... based the character Pip in remembrance of himself as a child, writing about his own thoughts and feelings to ... nervous and scared of her at the time. Estella was Miss Havishams adopted daughter, who was asked to play with Pip and break ...
Comparing Amy Tan's "Mother Tongue" and Gloria Anzuldua's "How To Tame A Wild Tongue"
... life (Tan 318). Amy Tan thought that while living in fear of not fitting in, the opportunities were taken away from her. The stunted language skill development, in immigrant families, could affect their success in school and other ...
Compare and contrast "I stand here ironing" and "how to talk to your mother".
... point-of-views, and languages. Lorrie Moore presents "How to Talk to Your Mother" in reverse chronological order, from latest to earliest. This technique supports her main idea by illustrating the broken communication pattern existing since the narrator's ...
A comparison between 'Tirra Lirra By the River' by Jessica Anderson, 'Diana: Queen of Hearts' and 'Starry Starry night' by Don Mclean in reference to the topic of Portraits
... is chronological order with nothing to hide. These Symbolic subjects are used as motifs in the novel. Like Nora Porteous, Princess Diana was also a bit of an outsider, pressured by family and searching ...