Explain why Plato thinks Philosophers should be Kings?
Plato's strategy in the Republic is to explicate the primary notion of societal or political justice and then parallel it to the concept of individual justice. Before he can prove that justice is a good thing, Plato must first state its definition, by showing justice in its perfect form in order to discover the true essence of it. Therefore, Socrates claims that the only way to have a perfect state is if the state has a perfect leader, thus he introduces the concept of the philosopher-king.
Plato identifies political justice as harmony in a structured political body. An ideal state consists of three main classes of people: producers, auxiliaries, and the guardians (rulers); a state is just when relations between these three classes are right. Justice is a principle of specialization: a principle that requires that each person fulfils the societal role to which nature fitted him or her, and does not interfere in any other business.
Socrates describes philosophers as "those who love the sight of truth" (475-e). He claims that what makes philosophers different from lovers of sights and sounds is that they apprehend the Forms. While lovers of sights and sounds love beautiful things, they are unable to see the nature of beauty itself. The Philosophers, on the other hand, believe that beauty exists and can see both it and the things it participates in. In order to back up this claim, that only philosophers can have knowledge, Socrates paints a metaphysical and epistemological picture. He divides the concept of knowledge into: what is, what is not and an intermediate between being and not being. This intermediate between knowledge and ignorance is what he defines as an opinion and casts it as a fallible power. Furthermore, knowledge is the strongest infallible power that is set over the...
More Contemporary Philosophy
essays:
Are you convinced by Plato's claim that philosophers should rule.
... his claim that philosophers should rule." The two concepts stated above are the fundamental ideas that Plato establishes as a starting point to argue for what is in essence a totalitarian society that is ruled by the philosopher guardians. Plato starts ...
Plato and his views on Rome
... be seen with any and all of it's leaders. Plato felt state leaders should be well-educated philosophers, in order to make wise decisions for the benefit of ... oppose these excesses" (Spielvogel 155). Cicero mentions a lot about justice as well, he says, "...we must believe that men have ...
"The kind of knowledge Plato has in mind in his theory of forms is not the kind of knowledge needed to rule a city".
... individuals. Plato assigns different political roles to different members of each class (Horowitz). It appears that the only classes that are allowed to participate in government are the auxiliaries and of course, the philosopher rulers. The ...
Was Socrates guilty or not?
... he claims that he was propositioned by the gods through the Oracle of Delphi, to question people's wisdom. Socrates said: "when god stationed me, as I supposed and assumed, ordering me to live philosophizing and ...
It is 300BC, you are a Platonist. Your friend, also a student, has been condemned to death by the Athenian court. Write him a letter preparing him for his last hours.
... own. Socrates was want to say that a philosopher should be an enemy of the body and ... other than virtue and wickedness including all which have the essence of virtue or wickedness, such as justice or injustice, courage or cowardice? And it was shown that ...
Explain the Criticisms of Plato's Theory of the Forms.
... who follow him, and even in this day and age Plato's ideas are understood and followed and he has ended up being one of the most influential philosophers although his Theory of Forms is slightly over the top ... world. Plato answers the question "what is beauty?" by discovering the essence of true beauty ...
According to Plato Justice occurs when all three parts of the whole perform there right proper functions. Explain Fully
... beast". Plato believes that the sole/mind and the emotions have to work together to suppress the bodily appetite. It also applies to society as a whole he thinks that the philosophers, the guardians, and the workers/producers. The ...
The Republic, written by Plato
... another philosopher and Socrates elder brother brought up the fact that we should take a look at the kinds of things people actually say when they get praised justice and ... thing and it is better to live a unjust life. Plato's elder brother Glaucon argues that the just man is ...