The failure of Marxism in Russia
Iain Pearson, 1st year, Modern History (BA Hons)
'Far from being the creature of ideology, in its essential features the Soviet state defied Marxist theory,' Discuss.
When the Tsarist regime in Russia was overthrown and the Bolshevik party under Lenin ruled
as a single party government, it was claimed by many that a Marxist regime had been
established. Many within the Bolshevik party were firm believers in the Marxist theory and
thought that the Soviet state would agree with Marx's ideas. There are some modern
historians who agree with this view, embracing the ideas of equality and fraternity and
believing that the Soviet state was the living embodiment of these beliefs. There are also
those who see that the Soviet state was something quite different from what Marx and indeed
Lenin had intended it to be. To find out whether the Soviet state defied Marxist theory or not,
is hardly a simple task of comparing the elements of the Soviet state with that of an ideal
Marxist state. One must look at how the regime arose, and in what circumstances, how
popular it was, and whether it was an inevitable manifestation. It is clear that the chief
coordinator of the revolution and founder of the movement, Vladimir Illyich Lenin died early
on in the regime. Therefore the change of rulers must be looked at closely to see whether
there were any major changes or internal disputes, which may cast doubt on the direction and
beliefs of the party. It is clear, therefore that to understand and assess whether the Soviet state
defied Marxist theory or not, one has to look at a number of features and assess their
importance. Perhaps also, it is worth considering how important Marxism is as an ideology,
that is to say, was it bound to...
More Specific Policies
essays:
Japanese Canadians
... Canadian government toward these people at the time. Although the relocation of Japanese Canadians was justified as a security measure, I do not agree with this explanation. Today we can look back at the history of this special ...
Early American Foreign Policy
... government into war, making drifts in the foreign policy that stated that America would not interact with colonies that existed before the Monroe Doctrine. With this competition, the American papers gained much political powers, for they had the American people believing ...
Aboriginal-self-government
... nations. With this definition we can now look at the Nunavut government. The ... single-level territorial court will be the primary institutions. Based on the Aboriginal tradition of group decision-making, the legislative assembly operates consensus-style without political parties ...
The history of zionism.
... Jewish state that existed during the days of the Old Testament. Zionists believe that this land is promised to them by God, and that they have, through the covenant they have made with God ...
Electoral College Reform.
... College. This method of electing the president, included in the structural foundation of our government within the United States Constitution, is the fundamental flaw within the process of presidential elections. It has been one of the most controversial institutions of modern ...
Was Machiavelli a Machiavellian?
... not believe an author to be either fully or partly agreeing with his subject matter I do think this may be the case with Machiavelli ... In modern society we tend to have a great deal of contempt for our leaders and as events in recent history have proved, this has ...
What is meant by 'international security'?
... or state vs. state basis. Examples of such power balance are clearly evident throughout history, e.g. the USSR vs. USA in the cold war and the resulting Warsaw Pact and NATO alliances yet this remains ...
The Environmental Implications of Political and Economic Reform in Communist China
... nature. With this shift from small regional based colonialism (which still saw strife between feudal regional elites) to full scale communism, Mao and the newly formed communist party sought ...