"The Human Rights act for ever changes the nature of British society, marking a major turning point in British Constitutional history." Discuss
Public Law Essay.
October 2001 saw the full implementation of The Human Rights Act 1998. Its effect was to incorporate the European Convention of Human rights into domestic law. This means that British Citizens can now rely upon Convention Rights in British courts and will not have to 'take the long slow road to the Court in Strasbourg'. A civilised society can only exist when the citizens of the State know their rights, respect their rights and fulfil their own obligations to society. It therefore, follows that knowledge of Human Rights and dignity is the very basics of a civilised and democratic state. To some the Act marks 'a fundamental constitutional change…' which represents a strong step forward in Britain establishing a quasi-Bill of Rights 'introducing new values and an altered frame of reference to UK public Law'. To others however, the Act is simply a 'British statute having in principle no different status from that of any other statute' and whose effects, can not be considered so 'far-reaching.' This essay will seek to identify the effects that the Act will have on both our constitution and our lives as British citizens.
Ostensibly, the Human Rights Act 1998 purports to confer upon British citizens 'rights'. It would seem appropriate therefore, if first, we explore exactly what is meant by the word 'rights' and determine whether in fact such a conferral changes anything at all.
Great Britain, almost uniquely amongst democratic Western states, has no comprehensive Bill of Rights. Instead 'rights' are to be adduced as the sum total of, liberty - less State imposed restriction. In other words 'every citizen has a right to do what he likes, unless restrained by the common law or statute.' Rights existing in such a way are commonly referred to as 'liberties'. Appraisal of...
Reviews of: ""The Human Rights act for ever changes the nature of British society, marking a major turning point in British Constitutional history." Discuss"
:
Not brilliabnt but well written essay that covers main points
More Law
essays:
"In Our View, Therefore, Medical Law is a Subset of Human Rights Law" (Kennedy, I & A. Grubb. Medical Law 3rd edition (2000))
... The Act has appeared in several health law cases over the past couple of years, its significance makes it essential that NHS bodies understand and consider the possible implications of the legislation. The incorporation of the European Convention of Human Rights ...
Contracts in restraint of trade
... jurisdiction of the court and contracts interfering with human rights. This group can be expanded upon and it is important to note that contracts in restraint of trade ... words means that they are presumed to be invalid unless the opposite is proven before the court. In "The modern Law of Contract ...
How has the Human Rights Act affected Parliamentary Supremacy?
... the European Convention of Human Rights 1950 Art.6(1) which makes sure that "everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing... by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law". This case allowed the courts to ...
Police Abuse
... public. This means that even the criminals, who are a part of the public, have certain rights, particularly, civil rights. All citizens must be aware of these rights to ... United States: A policy statement on the need for Federal oversight. New York: Human Rights Watch ...
Access and Equity in Australian Law
... the right to change. Naturally, the democratic world has developed much further to give, in actual fact, equal rights to women as men. When women say that they are disadvantaged in their access to the law, this is ...
Police Brutality
... public. This means that even the criminals, who are a part of the public, have certain rights, particularly, civil rights. All citizens must be aware of these rights to ...
Comparison of characteristics and perceptions of the Qld Criminal Justice System, Aboriginal Customary Law and Islamic Criminal Law according to crime and punishment procedures
... the state) has the Burdon of proof. This means that the prosecution must prove to the jury that the ... existence of the deterrent and low incidence of crime means that the hadd penalty, in practise, is rarely applied. The same applies to the other categories of hudud crimes. The right to ...
What improvements, if any, will there be to the present law on consent and on mistaken belief in consent in rape cases as a result of the Sexual Offences Bill 2003?
... positive obligation to protect its citizens more from rape as Art 4 of European Convention of Human Rights stipulates that a ...
This essay is a little long and drawn out.
i can understand why u got a grade like that. the essay skips around and gets confusing to a person that doesnt understand the subject totally in depth. The essay has very many references that shows that you tried hard, i think the paper was long but it did have a lot of information it in
5 out of 8 people found this comment useful.