ÃÂTo gain that which is worth having, it may be necessary to lose everything elseÃÂ. This quote has many implications in To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee. What Bernadette Devlin meant in this quotation is that sometimes, you basically have to give to get. In certain situations in life, we have to lose much in order to gain more. I agree with this quote. I find that itÃÂs definitely true that in life you have to give a lot, sometimes everything, in order to gain something of value. In three instances in To Kill a Mockingbird its proven true. In Atticus Finch agreeing to defend Tom Robinson, in Jem reading to Mrs. Dubose, and finally when Boo Radley saves the Jem and Scout from Bob Ewell.
One such example of losing everything in order to gain even more is when Atticus Finch agrees to defend Tom Robinson, a black man accused of raping a white woman.
In the racist South, for an established lawyer and respected man to defend a black man against a white woman was unheard of. But sometimes, to gain that which is worth having, it may be necessary to lose everything. In this case, the eminent FinchÃÂs lost their reputation and esteem in the community but the benefit outweighed the cost. Atticus knew that he had to do the right thing, and in this case that was defending the innocent Tom Robinson against the malicious rape charges. Because of AtticusÃÂ decision, Jem and Scout, his children, are subjected to abuse from other children, even when they celebrate Christmas at the family compound on FinchÃÂs Landing. So in the name of justice, not only did Atticus Finch give up everything to do what he believed right, but his children Jem and Scout did so as...
To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee
As a piece of writing, this essay is reasonably good. Sentences are structured as sentences; rules of grammar are followed. There are lapses: "according to roomers"?
Unfortunately, as a reflection of reading, it is unimpressive. First of all, white lawyers did rise to the defense of poor blacks accused of crimes in the South. Atticus' being asked to defend Tom Robinson is an example. A judge, knowing that a case demanded fair treatment, would turn to the best lawyer in the region, and ask for a pro bono defense. And people white and black acknowledged the distinction. Atticus did not lose his reputation and esteem in the community. If anything, that reputation was advanced. He was the lawyer of such uncompromising integrity that the community could call on him to make the impossible defense.
Similarly, Jem lost very little. To suggest he lost everything in having to read to Ms. DuBose is a clear exaggeration.
Boo Radley did not lose everything in killing Bob Ewell. Bob Ewell plainly lost more: he's out in the street with a butcher knife shoved up between his ribs.
The essay also fails to realize that town, collectively, were the losers. By the end of the case, most people realized that Atticus had shown them the truth: If Ella-May Ewell was raped, it was by her own father in punishment for her coveting the touch of Tom Robinson, a black man. But the town had to see what their unthinking racial hatred had done to realize that this was wrong. They lost everything. They may have gained the insight to do better.
1 out of 1 people found this comment useful.