Law Vs. Media
- Good, thought provoking paper
I have elected to write an essay dealing with not just a news event, but an action that can highly influence the news we see and hear. The action is known as 'shield laws.' These are codes that enable the media to tell us information, but not where the data came from. I stand very firmly on the belief that enabling persons to stay anonymous (especially in the judicial system) can effect the outcomes of various situations.
Law Vs Media
On July 4, 1967, a law entitled 'Freedom of Information Act,' was passed. This law states that the public has the right to all federal records dealing with almost any subject (excluding those matter's in reference to national security). The act has been used time and time again in court to reveal such information as JFK's murder and 'the UFO conspiracy.' However, this act was not formed solely to exploit the government's records, but also for the public's rights granted in the 6th Amendment. This bill states that a person has the right to a speedy trial, trial by one's peers, and the ability to cross examine his/her accuser(s). Therefore, in the case of journalists receiving information by 'anonymous sources,' these sources must be put on trial. However, by using 'shield laws,' the informants can remain anonymous. This in effect deems part of the 6th Amendment null. However, as stated, the loss of shield laws will result in a form a censorship. This brings up the point of which is more important: the law or the media?
To answer the question, you can not look in the Bill of Rights, since the 1st and 6th Amendments would act against one-another. Therefore, a judgment about 'shield laws' must be made. The decision must be broad to...
More Cases
essays:
Religious Freedom: Supreme Court Case Oregon Vs Smith
... when referring to the above-mentioned cases of precedent is that the activities carried out by those respondents were not illegal according to the laws of the state. Smith ...
Microsoft Antitrust Case
... 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act states Every contract, combination in the form of trust or otherwise, or conspiracy, in restraint of trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations, is declared to be ...
Defamation of a Prime Minister
... feelings of hatred, contempt, ridicule, fear and disesteem [Lecture Notes]. The given information clearly fulfils the first criteria, the statement is blatantly defamatory, and it was both a libel and an innuendo. The second criterion is: the statement must refer to ...
The Lindebergh Case and how the case relates to current US laws, and what society was like in the 1930's.
... The act must be committed in the jurisdiction of the United States and/or in United States air jurisdiction. The law states that if two or more people work together to kidnap ...
Describe and analyse the forces shaping the employment relationship in the firefighters' case study referred to in the tutorial in Week 12 (Blyton and Turnbull, 2004:317-325).
... basis of the exchange system. It protects the individual worker in that it provides a counterbalancing force in regard to "the inequality of bargaining ...
Supreme Court Case: Engel v. Vitale Analysis
... According to the First Amendment, the enactment of any law establishing a religion is prohibited. Under the supervision of the Constitution, Congress cannot interfere with the freedom of religion; however, the Fourteenth Amendment does not allow the states (or ...
Constitution of Express Trusts/UK Law
... wished to appoint him the future director of the company; and she informed him ... the law that relates to perfect constituted gifts and trusts will not be appropriate. Moreover, the axiom of equity will intervene: "equity will not perfect an imperfect gift". The state of equity ...
I discuss in the essay below to what extents have the latest judicial decissions eroded the employers' business interests?
... and of gaining access to that information when necessary, decrease within these circumstances. In addition, these developments may result in protecting the unscrupulous employee and offer him more advantages from the freedom of contract ...