Martin Luther King, Jr. described an unjust law as being "a code that is out of harmony
with the moral law." He believed that people have a responsibility to disobey unjust laws. I agree
with that statement because a law is something that everyone should believe in, and not something
that holds a community back. African Americans in Birmingham were being treated unfairly, and
I strongly agree that they have a right to disobey the prejudiced laws that denied them of their
rights.
African Americans in Birmingham were not being treated like Americans (or humans for
that matter). They deserved the same rights as everyone else, but they were unfairly denied those
rights. They spoke out against unjust laws, and also tried negotiating with authorities and
government officials many times, however, they were not successful. As a last resort, they
disobeyed the unethical laws, and I feel that was the right thing for them to do.
They knew that
by rebelling against the laws that they would have to pay the consequences, and they did so
anyway because it was their responsibility to bring attention to the laws in order to attempt to get
them changed.
I feel that it was okay for the people to disobey the laws because it brought much needed
attention to the issues that others, who were unaffected, were trying to ignore. The African
American community in Birmingham should have been given all the same rights as everyone else
in America. In Montgomery, Rosa Parks disobeyed the law that made her and her fellow black
citizens sit on the back of the bus. Her feet were tired and she did not feel that she should be
forced to stand just so that a white person could sit. When she refused to get up, she brought...
Pretty good, need more examples
After my paper was graded my professor said that my essay didn't really focus on the main question: Do you agree with the statement, "people have a responsibility to disobey unjust laws?" I used the word "right" a lot in the essay, however, responsibility and right are two different things. I also could have used more examples in my essay. I focused on Martin Luther King's era and the 1960's, and my main reference was MLK's "Letter From Birmingham Jail." Thinking back on it, I could have used examples like homosexual marriage and things of that nature. Overall I believe I wrote a pretty good essay, but it could be better with a little more thought.
4 out of 4 people found this comment useful.