The Unokai
In 23 years of field work, Napoleon Chagnon has observed and recorded the histories of 60 Yanomami villages. In recent years, his writings have contributed to the label of the Yanomami as a 'fierce' people. He has created an image of these people which is not only questionable from an anthropological perspective, but also an image that has brought detriment to their society as a whole. By analyzing Chagnon's interpretations of the Yanomami lifestyle, one sees that his ideas are highly influenced by western standards of life and can be rethought using basic non-biased logic.
One of the central arguments that the Yanomami are a violent people is the presence of unokai in Yanomami society, a word Chagnon translates as 'killer.' These unokai are, as defined by Chagnon, men who have either killed another person or were involved in the attack which led to the killing. Although his arguments presented in a 1988 article of Science magazine do not go into great detail about the process of gaining the title of unokai, he centers many of his points around the unokai and their actions.
Of the 283 deaths Chagnon recorded in 23 years among the Yanomami, he attributes 153 of these to unokai who were living when the article was published. He goes on to state that almost everyone in the villages he has visited had a family member or kinsman killed by blood revenge or because of a unokai hunting party. Because of this supposed high incidence of violence and its effect on a large portion of the population, he leads the reader to the conclusion the Yanomami are an exceedingly savage society and that the unokai epitomize this idea.
Chagnon's ideas are in contrast to those presented by Bruce Albert in his 1989 article in Current Anthropology. Albert,
More Anthropology
essays:
Chagnon's definition of unokai in regards to the Yanomami.
... an anthropological perspective, but also an image that has brought detriment to their society as a whole. By analyzing Chagnon's interpretations of the Yanomami lifestyle, one sees that his ideas are highly influenced by western standards of ...
Social and Cultural anthropology: What defines and justifies the study of the discipline.
... a culturally heterogeneous environment. The global and holistic knowledge that anthropological perspectives bring, are equally valuable within the profession as outside it ...
Guidelines for Gay/Lesbian/Bisexual-Affirmative Educational Practices in Graduate Psychology Programs
... at one developing campus (Diehm & Lazzari, 2001), many faculty, staff, and administrators reported a great deal of rhetoric around fostering nondiscrimination but less than adequate action. In recent years, many ...
Medical Risks & Factors for Body Modifications
... throughout history, and has increased tremendously in popularity in recent years (Alaga, 2003). Known health risks from piercing include, the transfer of sexually transmitted diseases, a break in skin can produce local infections, scarification, or HIV infection. One major ...
Cultural Anthropology, Indigenous peoples
... years. According to Plumley, D. Ancient cultures apparently made the transition from hunting reindeer to domestication and a nomadic lifestyle moving their reindeer to new high mountain taiga and tundra ...
Africa and Multi-Regional
... of years ago. And to take a theory like Multi-Regionalism and split off of the Out of Africa group is also exciting. It not only gives new life to the argument and new perspectives but ...
To describe and compare cultural attitudes and approaches to preventing ill health.
... it has been proven to be successful for hundreds of years, but also because western medicine is very expensive and therefore unfeasible for many. Many ... place the causation of illness on hereditary factors rather than lifestyle, or believe the reason they have a cold is due ...
Canada - of the United States of America
... happen between 1947 and 1957 but if you research any year in modern trading history between Canada and the United States you will come to ... not underestimate the constant pressure on Canada which the mere presence of the United States has produced. We're different people ...