September 2007 Von Hannover v. Germany CONSTITUTIONAL LAW Few decisions of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter ECtHR) have received as much media attention as the judgment in the case under review, in which the princess of Monaco, Caroline von Hannover, defended her right to privacy against intrusions by paparazzi and the tabloid press. The Third Section of the Court held unanimously that Germany had violated the applicant's right to privacy under the European Convention on Human Rights (hereinafter ECHR),2 when its courts, including the Federal Constitutional Court, denied her damages for the publication of pictures showing her shopping, in a restaurant courtyard, and at a private beach club. In weighing the right to privacy with the freedom of the press (articles 8 and 10 of the convention, respectively), the seven judges found that there was no public interest in knowing facts of an essentially private nature that could override the applicant's privacy right. Despite heavy lobbying by media corporations, the German government decided against requesting a referral of the case to the Grand Chamber for review under article 43 of the convention.3 The German Federal Constitutional Court subsequently hinted that it does not consider itself obliged to bring its own case law fully in line with this judgment.4 The case is the last in a series of proceedings brought by the applicant in German courts against the publication of pictures of her and her family. The German Federal Court, the highest civil court, determined that the public's interest in pictures showing "public figures"5 outweighs their right to privacy unless they have retreated to a secluded place.6 The Federal Constitutional Court largely upheld this judgment, reversing and remanding it only with respect to pictures that showed the applicant with her children. The German Constitution particularly protects the relationship... |
Von Hanover VS Germany: Privacy Law since the HRA
More Law & Government Essays
essays:
Women's Right to Vote
... to get the vote. The AWSA directed its efforts toward getting states to give women the right to vote. Anthony believed that this would take to long and tried to the the courts to declare that voting is the right of all citizens. She based this belief on the fact that ...
Sexism in the Workplace
... of how to cope (Allen 1993 p26). The Employment Act 1978 gives women going through pregnancy and child birth the right to have time off with no loss of position. This is only given however to ...
Domestic abuse
... to similar fantasies, sure the goodness and charm would return--if they could love him better, do everything right. When someone abuses another person they often have a certain attitude such as thinking that it is the abused persons fault and that ...
The Feminine Mystique
... 's fueled a lot of strong movements and the Gay Rights Movement was one of the many that came out of this decade. Gaining a lot of momentum from the ideas of acceptance and equality sparked by the Civil Rights Movement, the Gay Rights Movement set out to achieve acceptance in ...
An Ethical and Practical Defense of Affirmative Action
... right to equal opportunity precedence over their parents? The adults have lived longer without the chance at equal opportunity and I believe that their restitution would take precedence if we had to choose. Affirmative action policies should encompass the eldest and youngest of ...