Comparison between "Our Town: (Thorton Wilder) and the motion picture "Steel Magnolias" (based on Robert Harling's original stage play)

Essay by eskucHigh School, 11th gradeA+, March 2005

download word file, 2 pages 3.0

Downloaded 22 times

Our Town vs. Steel Magnolias

To the casual observer, Our Town, the theatrical piece by Thornton Wilder, is very different from the cinematic production entitled Steel Magnolias (based on Robert Harling's original stage play). Due to their differences in setting, characters, and mood, it can be difficult to see the obvious parallels. A more in-depth look at both pieces reveals many similarities in different areas, such as daily life, love, marriage, and death.

Despite the fact that Our Town takes place between 1901 and 1913 and Steel Magnolias is set in the late 1980s, an average day in Grover's Corners is much like one in Chinquapin. Both of these fictional cities demonstrate small-town life. On an ordinary day, in both cities, the newsboys make their morning rounds delivering the daily newspapers to the townspeople. In Chinquapin, the delivery man distributes parcels to their recipients, while the milkman in Grover's Corners delivers his goods.

A skirmish between George and Rebecca Gibbs corresponds to that of Shelby's brothers, Jonathon and Tommy.

This pair of presentational life dramas is alike in relation to love and marriage as well as daily life. Both stories, as a result of love, have wedding components. In both weddings, the grooms feel nervous about their futures. They are overcome by potential feelings of sorrow and abundant happiness. Both of the men want to see their brides on the day of the wedding, and are told that it is bad luck to do so. The parents also demonstrate "cold feet" by showing that they, too are nervous not only for their children, but also for themselves and the part of their lives that their children occupy.

The final way in which these pieces are alike is the most important and profound way. It pertains to life and death, and...