Explain briefly Ninian Smart's seven dimensional model of religion. Do you think that Smart's model solves the problems that arise when attempting to define religion?

Essay by trinidadUniversity, Bachelor's November 2006

download word file, 5 pages 2.0

Downloaded 86 times

For centuries Scholars have struggled to come up with a neatly defined term for what constitutes a religion.

Many scholar definitions are either substantive or functional. Substantive definitions distinguish religion by common beliefs and practices such as (rituals, prayer or belief in one god). Substantive definitions tend to be too narrow and prejudiced; it would be difficult to consider Buddhism, which is atheistic, as a religion under this definition.

Functional definitions tend to distinguish a religion by the needs it fulfils, (peace, comfort, security), the problem with functional definitions is they tend to be to flexible and vague to be considered as definite solutions to what exactly makes a religion "a religion" since there is no clear boundary to where a religion ends and something else such as a political movement or cult begins.

Recent scholars have attempted to emphasize the broad nature of religion rather than define it within a narrow framework.

One of the best known of these attempts is the seven dimensional model proposed by Ninian Smart, who suggested we approach each religion by looking at it under a number of different dimensions. These are:

The practical & ritual dimension

Smart explains that religions tend to express themselves through rituals. Rituals vary greatly among religions and may include activities such as worship, preaching, prayer and meditation. Sometimes these religious practices are elaborate; Catholics break bread and drink wine to symbolise the body and blood of Jesus and sometimes less elaborate; meditation practice in Buddhism or the Quakers who sit together in silence.

The experiential & emotional dimension

The next dimension involves the importance of emotions and experiences in a religion. Just as the rituals of religious practice vary so do the religious experience. The enlightenment of the Buddha, the visionary experiences of Muhammad and the suffering...