A Small Consolation Battling against Diversity in Higher Education

Essay by msbonnielaneUniversity, Bachelor'sA+, July 2004

download word file, 6 pages 5.0

I. Utilitarianism


Non-Minority Students--Affirmative action provides an advantage to some people because of the color of their skin.

Minority Students--Lowering admissions standards for certain minority groups brings about stereotypes that members of those groups are less intelligent because it implies that nobody from these groups is smart enough to get into college on his or her own merits. This sort of stereotyping perpetuates the inequalities that affirmative action seeks to eliminate.

Businesses--Possibilities that under qualified people may be put into positions despite their lack of knowledge (in effort to meet the unspoken "minority quota")


Non-Minority and Minority Students--Students can learn a lot from one another, but only if the student body contains representatives of a wide range of backgrounds.

Minority Students--aids in encouraging minority students who are under represented in our institutes of higher learning to seek higher education.

Minority Students--Affords opportunity to qualified students who, due to circumstances beyond their control, do not have the ability to attend a specialized (expensive) college.

II. Deontological

There are several factors that a college should take into account when considering applicants, such as grades, test scores, and extra-curricular achievements. Recently,

the courts ruled that those school's that follow an affirmative action policy, which considers race as a factor in admissions but does not assign specific weight to it, does not violate the equal protections clause of the 14th Amendment. Race and ethnicity are incredibly important in American society and it would be foolish to think that a community made up entirely of one race could provide the same range of perspectives as a racially diverse one. Is it logical to think that a white male attending an exclusively white, all male college, is going to find a job upon graduating that only hires white males? This is possible, but not...