Compose an argument for or against that ÃÂevery text has a use-by dateÃÂ.
Consider your prescribed textsÃÂ ideas, language and form, and its reception in different contexts.
To make the argument that ÃÂevery text has a use by date,ÃÂ would be quite fickle and small minded as texts often have deeper meanings, and the themes explored generally have universal appeal. Although the text itself may not change, people from different contexts will identify different meanings from it, and thus it will always have importance to responders. This is especially true for the poetry of Gwen Harwood, in particular ÃÂThe Glass JarÃÂ and ÃÂAlter EgoÃÂ which lend themselves to a Christian, Freudian or modernist interpretation.
Although, ÃÂthe Glass JarÃÂ and ÃÂAlter EgoÃÂ are two different works, they do share a similar style and a coherence of form. Like HarwoodÃÂs other poems, they adhere to a strict rhyme scheme, with sophisticated language.
Additionally, her poems show a preoccupation with the holistic idea of the human experience, dealing with universal themes of life, death, dreams and the nature of self, showing that her poems all link well together, as they are ÃÂpart of one work, product of one mind,ÃÂ thus achieving textual integrity.
On a literal level, ÃÂThe Glass JarÃÂ is a universal story about a boyÃÂs crippling fear of the dark and the difficult journey of growth and experience that everyone must go through. After a nightmare, a boy tries to release the sunÃÂs rays that he captured in a jar. Failing that, he approaches his mother but finds her ÃÂin her rivalÃÂs fast embraceÃÂ. Bereaved of his ÃÂcomforter,ÃÂ he faces his fears alone and wakes up in the morning, becoming more mature through bitter experience.
However, one coming from a primarily Christian context, will see that there is another side...