The Dilemma of the Philosopher and the City
The Dilemma of the Philosopher and the City
In the third wave in Book V of the Republic, Socrates proposes his idea of the philosopher-king (473d). The philosopher, Socrates claims, is superior to anyone else in any respect, and hence he should be king. Notwithstanding his superiority, the philosopher does not want to deviate from philosophy and be the ruler. The citizens also rebel against the rule of the philosopher, because they cannot understand the virtue of philosophy. Hence philosopher cannot be the ruler in any existing city. Moreover, philosophy is more of a danger to the imperfect city in which the philosopher is not the king, namely, all existing cities. It may be abused and lead to evil. And philosophy itself always goes against the imperfect regime, for it strives after justice. Philosophy and the city need each other as well as conflict with each other. Because on the one hand, the citizens do not appreciate the superiority of philosophy, and on the other hand, the philosopher in the imperfect city may do harm to the regime, the real city cannot accommodate the philosopher.
The philosopher, and only the philosopher, is qualified to be the king for three reasons: he is the most just man, he can see the underlying truth of the city and he requires nothing from the city. As defined in Book IV, justice of a city is when the other three virtues, wisdom, courage and moderation, are in the right place, which is to say, those with wisdom rule and the others obey. Analogically, justice of a man is that the wisdom within him rules. The philosopher, as "friends and kinsman of truth, justice, courage, and moderation" (487a), is such man, the most just man. The true philosopher, as "the lover of the sight of...
More Classical Philosophy
essays:
Socrates on Athenian law and obedience
... stop philosophizing as it was against the gods will (Apology 29d). Socrates also says "be sure that this is what the god orders me to do, and I think there is no greater blessing for the city than ...
Aristotle
... what philosophy is and about what it can do and this affected his political thought. His main disagreement concerned Plato's forms. Plato had been trying to answer Socrates' question; what is beauty? And what is justice? Plato ...
Socratic dialectic
... the Socratic method. The ultimate aim of Socrates' philosophical method is ethical. Sceptical of the conflicting theories regarding the physical world of whom "some conceived existence as ...
Stoicism
... and philosophy like Socrates, Plato and Aristotle, the Stoics are considered by many as representatives of a philosophical system of deuterogenic importance. Stoicism revisited Pre-Socratic theories ...
What according to Socrates is a just city
... feared." Socrates and Glaucon find that the people in the city who exhibit this courageous behavior are the guardians of the city. The class system is based upon the knowledge of the forms, therefore the philosopher kings and ...
How Does Socrates Show That Justice is Not Possible in the City?
... two waves have been overcome, at this point political justice does not seem impossible but merely difficult to achieve. Socrates suggests that this communal living is possible if the rulers were philosophers. So he asks are philosopher kings desirable ...
The Life Of Reason
... superiority of leading a life of reason. As Socrates puts it, the "unexamined life is not worth living for a human being." Yet, there is much controversy over the beliefs of Socrates. Many people are in disagreement with his conflicting philosophic ...
The Trial Of Socrates
... of Socrates is that a city famous for free speech prosecuted a philosopher guilty of no other crime than exercising it. The trial of Socrates was ... the ruler to give orders and of the ruled to obey. He denied that citizens had the virtue needed ...