Against death penalty.

Essay by asia2redCollege, UndergraduateA+, January 2004

download word file, 3 pages 3.7 3 reviews

Downloaded 94 times

Listen to the voice of Justice and Reason. It tells us that human judgements are never

so certain as to permit society to kill a human being judged by other human beings. Why

deprive ourselves of any chance to redeem such errors? Why condemn yourself to

helplessness when faced with persecuted innocence.

I know there are those who say that execution is justified because it prevents a

murderer from ever again committing the same crime. It certainly does. But if you rely on

that reasoning you are killing a man not because his death may deter others from following

in his footsteps, but because of what he might possibly do at some future time. To justify such

preventive execution, there would have to be some reasonable grounds for believing that a

convicted murderer, if released into society, would murder again. In fact the probability lies

strongly in the other direction.

In order to be absolutely sure that no murderer would murder

again, we would have to take the lives of all people convicted of either first or second degree

murder, even though the probability is that an infinitesimal percentage of them would never

commit murder again if allowed to live. That's an unacceptable high price to pay in human

lives for a sense of security insignificantly greater tan we have now.

I have seen the movie " Dead Man Walking" for the first time just before I first wrote

this down. The film is loaded with death penalty advocates. The film makers present their

feelings and arguments honestly, as far as I can tell. But they all ring hollow to me,

because they all dehumanize the criminal. Well, just like you may say, let's execute the

murderer for the crime he has committed. Let's take a life for a...