Capital Punishment and Religion.
Empirical adequacy, logical consistence, and personal relevance are three simple tests that can be used to prove truth. When applied to a situation that involves a death row prisoner who has found God, the result may not be so simple. The complicating factor in this situation is the motive of the inmate and if he is using the attachment to God as a means.
The evidence that supports a person on death row, who claims to have found God, has to be his actions. The existence of God cannot be physically proven; therefore faith alone is not enough evidence to make this a strong argument. Empirical adequacy is physical evidence. Has this person demonstrated the behavior of a God-loving or rehabilitated individual? Death row prisoners form positive relationships, go to church, and even take steps to further their education. Although these characteristics are present, did they originate from a person who is devoted to the word of God or a person who fears death? The application of further tests must be made.
Logical consistency and personal relevancy are the next two steps in proving truth. Is it logically consistent for a person who has committed an abhorrent crime to adhere to religion? A natural law philosopher such as Thomas Aquinas would concur. God is the creator and the ultimate source of reality. It is possible to loathe the sin and love the sinner. No matter how heinous the crime, everyone ought to have the right to life. There is personal relevance in this issue on both sides of the argument, but the belief in the convicted felon is vital for the prisoner himself and is indeed more prevalent. Prevention of death is key.
According to other philosophers such as John Locke and Robert Nozik, the right to life is also...
Reviews of: "Capital Punishment and Religion."
:
Although short, this article is articulate and demonstrates a logical thought process.
Though I don't necessarily agree with some of your views, your case is well thought out and well presented, leaving little room for argument or criticism, particularly in your references to Aquinas, Locke and Nozik. A little short, but it stayed on topic nicely.
Keep up the good work.
I believe there is truth in this. Even though the death row inmate has found God, or not, there is still a punishment for what he did. Once one person was let off the hook, everyone would be claiming to have found God. Well written essay with no mistakes.
Definately a great topic.
Your essay is wonderful. It really made me think about my morals and ethics.
well done
More Comparative Philosophy & Ethics
essays:
The existence of God (or lack thereof)
... the existence of god, for the fact that mathematical formulas in nature are so interrelated and exact. He fails to recognize that the formulas must be so interrelated or nothing would work. The word is ...
Is Abraham Admirable? The Arguments of Kant versus Kierkegaard. Immanuel Kant's "Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morals" and Soren Kierkegaard's "Fear and Trembling". (7 page paper)
... admirable person because of his superior faith and his fight of authenticity and being ethically moral. Today we encounter relationships to Kant and Kierkegaard's arguments in laws, duties, life struggles, and ethical culture. Today we have many laws that although ...
Does the fact that we might be deceived by an evil demon mean that we actually do not know anything?
... the existence of (a benevolent) God who, being perfectly good, would not deceive him. Towards the end of his Meditations, Descartes can even claim that an external world exists, because ...
Agnosticism
... the existence of God. Agnosticism uses the problem of evil to prove to both the atheists and the theists that, given the knowledge that the ...
The conflicting evolutionary theories of Darwin and Lamarck Over the years, philosophers, religious thinkers and scientists have tried to explain the history of life on Earth.
... lifetime because of the lack of evidence to back up his theory. Lamarck knew that gradual ... the history of the Earth, many people believe that God created every organism on the Earth ... suggested that all life on Earth gradually evolved over time from simple organisms. However, their knowledge of science ...
The Argument from Design, and the Problem of Evil
... prove the existence of a God as conceived in Christianity. In other religions, such as Islam, misery and suffering in 'this life' are reimbursed with rewards in the next. It is part of belief in Islam, that any person who is ...
"Integrity Crisis in Moral Conscience and the 21st Century"
... recognition of the existence of God, the goodness of being, and the goodness of other persons" (289). In our modern world today we have rejected God. In ... human being, and what it is to have an interpersonal relationship. Because we can't explain these questions we have come ...
The Existance of Free Will
... must exist simply because the entire world or even the simple workings of one man's brain cannot be described completely using only the laws of nature. A complex moral decision is created in the mind of men by more that ...
Capital Punnishement
Very good essay. Well researched and thought out. Stays on topic ery well.
15 out of 15 people found this comment useful.